Thursday, 29 December 2016

Thoughts about Ethics and Science, cases of unethical practice.

Community issues, sometimes of a scientific nature, involve differences of thinking and behaviour. Our codes of ethics in New Zealand offer a set of guidelines which bring consistency to decision making surrounding community issues. Therefore, codes of ethics need to reflect the highest moral values.

But what happens when codes are based on societal beliefs and norms, instead of what is considered moral?  

What are the risks that doctors, scientist, the government, or individuals face when challenging the norms of society?  

Can we feel confident that our national codes of ethics protect and support all who are at stake?  

Do codes of ethics draw lines which divide what is acceptable and unacceptable in a moral world, or do they reflect the criterion of the public at large?

One would hope that the bulk of the population in New Zealand act morally and insist on codes of ethics for our science communities, which reflect morality.

 A well-known example of the past, which challenged morality, are the social laws and ethics which existed in the deep south of America in the late 1700's right through till the introduction of the Thirteenth Amendment in 1865. These codes of ethics were probably based on societal norms rather than moral theories.  In the mid-1800's there were an estimated four million slaves living in the United States  (Bourne, 2008). Laws within those states not only permitted slavery but encouraged its activity, supporting the cotton industry to bring economic advantage to the region.

Even in current times, ethical codes in some areas of the world reflect the cultural beliefs and traditions of the people, rather than what we would consider moral. Look, for example, at the approval of female circumcision in African and Middle Eastern countries, or the strict government laws against abortion in Ireland.  Laws in North Carolina, USA made homosexual activity illegal until as late as 2003. What may seem morally wrong to some, are ethically correct to others, and this is directed by social beliefs and norms. 

I have used these social examples to highlight how culture hugely affects what we deem ethical.   So, how does the outside world view our ethics codes in New Zealand?  In science, I believe there is unethical practice in how we prioritise funding for scientific research and development. What is happening in front of us influences how we spend our resources.  If the global crisis in health is not affecting us directly, then where in our codes are we ensuring that we THINK globally?  The World Health Organisation (2016) explain in their website that there are parts of the world which are lacking resources to combat diseases.  These diseases are killing and disabling millions of people every year. 

We have to question if our codes of ethics ensure that New Zealand's scientific research adds value to our global population.  Our codes of ethics should steer the science community in New Zealand to minimise the inequality which occurs between first world countries (the founders of scientific research), and those regions which have little or no access to scientific resources of their own. Either through lack of funding, lack of education regarding urgent global issues or a lack of morals, New Zealand tends to funnel what is available, towards the benefit of our own society and financial interests. 

Whether we are considering the atrocities of Slavery, the procedure of female circumcision, or prioritising beauty over the treatment of life-threatening diseases, codes of ethics do not always ensure morality,  but instead reflect the norms of their founding societies. New Zealand has to continue to question and analyse their codes of Ethics to ensure we are not writing guidelines simply for our own comfort.


References:

Bourne, J. (2008, March).  Slavery in the United States.  EH.Net Encyclopedia. Retrieved from http://eh.net/encyclopedia/slavery-in-the-united-states/ 

World Health Organisation. (2016).  Why are some tropical diseases called neglected? Retrieved from http://www.who.int/features/qa/58/en/


Thursday, 15 December 2016

The important things in science writing.


In the mountain bike world where expletives, slang, and the use of profanities seem to replace intelligent vocabulary, there is the assumption that mountain bikers are talented with their bodies but not their communication.  I must admit, that I have heard more 'F-bomb's' in my 20 years of riding than is good for my ears, and slang is so commonplace that a person outside of the industry would be confused listening.  However, before we completely drill the average mountain biker's language, let's look at some reasoning for this behaviour.

We must consider that culture is influenced significantly by the style of communication used within a community.  The detail of the language used in mountain biking will chop and change over time. However, the genre will probably always remain informal, faddish, and suitable to how people feel when they are out on their bikes; out of their working hours and relaxing in the outdoors.  It is no surprise, therefore, that relaxed vocabulary follows, and the slang and especially expletives indicate that the speaker is lazy with their vocabulary, something to be expected on a Sunday afternoon at the bike park.

Going back to the elite athletes of the industry, is it right they take on the slangy lazy aspect of the culture? Of course, it is.  Elite athletes in any sporting code get away with poor language conduct because primarily they are a representation of those at grass roots level.  Once in a while, TV1 would turn up at a race for an interview, or the paper needed questions answered, and it always amused me that the athletes completely changed their language style to suit a national 6 pm news audience. 

The important thing to note here is that the athletes were not just putting on a show for the cameras; they understood that the language had to suit the audience, and to be listened to they needed to change their style to convey the message. Within the industry itself, the message is sent with slang. Outside the industry, a more formal vocabulary is required.


Science writing, its culture, and its audience, has created a genre of its own. Like a mountain biker talking to the NZ Herald or another rider, the style they use will be chosen to share the message as successfully as possible. That is the most important thing in communication, the use of language to inform; using a context which is most productively understood. Science, with its complex nature and new ideas, needs a writing style with the vocabulary so precise that there is no loss of message at any point of the literature. In Science, sentences need to be literal, ideas decisive, and individual words need to be as close fitting as possible; the 'F-bomb' may give emphasis, but its scope is far too wide for use in science. Rhetorical context is important in any industry, but in science communication needs to be represented by conciseness and brevity. Let's leave the 'F-bombs' to the mountain bikers.

Sunday, 11 December 2016

Christmas feast 2016; servings of organ donation information

Christmas is fast approaching. In NZ we are encouraged to shower ourselves in the spoils which this country allows. Who's house are we celebrating at this year?  Are we going to have seafood and lamb, or ham and turkey? Should we drink wine, beer, spirits or all three? Which flavour chocolate should I choose from Roses chocolate box? Of course, the options in front of us all have their pros and cons and we probably prefer one privilege over another. However, at days end, these yuletide questions are of no consequence, and we can be confident that any choice we make will have a positive outcome. 

This year, in the build-up to Christmas, I have been studying the differing viewpoints in the debate surrounding organ transplantation, in particular, priority allocation for those committed to healthy living.  Not all the choices laid out before us regarding the ultimate gift-of-life will have a positive outcome for those involved and therefore the topic is a highly debated and controversial array of alternatives. It is certainly no box of chocolates.

While studying different literature I soon learned that wringing out the essentials from each piece of literature required critical review. With so many avenues to consider, I decided to chose one article which steers towards ideas repeated in more than a couple of sources. The other article, I decided to pick an article which delved into a new idea for discussion.

My number one article was: Tongs "Community Preferences for the Allocation of Solid Organs for Transplantation". It bore the same fruits as other articles which I found. Like others, it leant towards a variety of predilections from the general public. Any Article bearing a title with the word 'Community' within its heading was bound to look at a broad audience for its conclusion, a conclusion which offered a balanced view of principles involved in allocating donated organs. These principles included efficiency, social, ethical, and medical values.  Above all, I felt the article was written to offer insight into a wide range of public opinion, rather than to persuade. 

My second choice of an article conveyed a unique idea; Persad and others share with us The Lancet journal article 'Principles for allocation of scarce medical interventions'. The authors give accounts of allocation principles which have been used individually, and in different formulas, to create assessment systems for organ and other medical intervention allocation. Instead of simply explaining why the principles are popular within communities, the authors analyse how the use of such principles individually or together as systems can be flawed. The position of the paper is to introduce to the audience a new system which they believe will be fair in successfully allocating scarce medical interventions.

 Both of these articles, full of information, give a clear indication that the subject of organ donor allocation is both complex and the debate is relevant to the community as a whole. With so much information on the subject and so much at stake, it is essential that the discussion continues until there are clear guidelines for allocation of organs with maximum benefits. Thankfully, much information is available for more discussion on the topic. Having access to the internet for research replicates the bounty of the NZ Christmas; the internet serves up a plethora of information, just as Christmas serves up an abundance of gluttony. 

Sources discussed:
- Tong, A., et al. (2010). Community Preferences for the Allocation of Solid Organs for Transplantation: A Systematic Review. Transplantation 89(7): 796-805.

- Persad, G., et al. Principles for allocation of scarce medical interventions. The Lancet 373(9661): 423-431.

Sunday, 4 December 2016

The Literature

Burst my bubble

Playing catch up is not the best way to pass summer school if you want to see the letter "A" on your paper. I Started my work a week earlier than the course commencement date, which gave me a false impression that I would not have to rush at any time during the semester.  However, my first time entering the Massey University website emulated the concept of "the opening of a can of worms", where each new information pathway acknowledged that there were ten more to view and learn.

More cans of worms

Week two was no easier. Researching for assignment one conveyed a similar undertone. Initially, I set a smart plan out for myself. The plan went something like this:

1) Analyse the topic, brainstorm, and then list ideas.

2) Follow this up with a general reading of popular journals to broaden my knowledge and add to my list of brainstormed ideas.

3) From this thoughts list, come up with a theme which is both unique and has some substance to it.

4) Choose six or so ideas from my list which create an understanding of the theme

5) Research these six ideas in full.

I was so happy with my well-thought-out plan; I went to bed content. The next day, I worked on my other paper; Psychology as a Social Science, and successfully opened so many cans of worms, that I was distracted from my Communication in the Sciences Assignment for a couple of days.

By the time I returned to the assignment, my peaceful feeling of control had vanished. I took a knee-jerk reaction and went straight from step 1), skipped steps 2), 3), and 4), and headed into full literature researching on the insufficient amount of ideas I had down on paper.

Making the best of a bad decision

Going into literature researching with an unedited list of ideas has not been the most efficient way to approach researching. The weak and unfocused list I had to work from meant I was spending quality time accumulating detail on subjects which I may not use at all.
Aside from that, researching literature as a whole was quite successful for me. I used Massey library and searched "articles/databases" which was an excellent avenue for primary sources of literature. I also tapped into the "toolkits" options under "research/services", where I found Google Scholar, Scopus, and Web of Science, other useful channels to find primary sources. A couple of skills I gained from the OWLL page was the use of the "advanced search" button and the Boolean operators to narrow down or expand my search.

A major lesson learnt

In hindsight, skipping important steps, of accumulating ideas before entering the literature research stage, saved me no time at all.  I have since had to go back to the drawing board and better my appreciation of the topic as a whole and adding ideas which bring focus to my research. Week two's Lesson 1 gave me tips on skim reading, and I have found reading the abstract and conclusions, then following up if the Author is an accepted authority is an excellent way to accumulate quality resources quickly.

Like all things in life, all the successes, and all the failures are beneficial in the end.  As I head into week three, I am happy for the cans of worms which keep opening. Regardless of the feelings of uneasiness, the learning is piecing together nicely and every can of worms will help create the big picture of Communication in the Sciences.

Sunday, 27 November 2016

1: A new Life

Here I am, new to academia, new to the scope of Massey University, and new to anything non-bike related. After 20 years of racing mountain bikes and BMX for New Zealand, I can say with hand on heart that this first week, as a university student, is one of the most challenging weeks of my life.  My name is Lisa Horlor, and this is my first attempt at a blog, my first attempt at being a student at Massey University, and my first attempt at distance learning. 

Along with Blog writing, readings of "scientific research papers", passages about "thinking objectively", and other foreign activities this week, has made my brain feel like it has just completed the equivalent of a week's training with Arnold Schwarzenegger.  I thought the areas of my brain associated with focus and tenacity would have been capable enough to handle study easily.  After all, racing has taken me to challenging parts of the world, encouraged me to work towards demanding goals,  challenged me with physical pain, and pushed me into zones of mental discomfort.  However, in 20 years, nothing has prepared me for week 1 of university study. I am hoping I quickly acclimatise to study.

These days the world of elite sport and science crosses over, with the desire from athletes to understand the science involved to train mind and body.  However, most of the information athletes use in their day to day training, is knowledge taken from university research. This fact made me consider attending Massey so that I could be more proactive in my understanding of the mind. 

 After nearly 20 years of chasing the ability to perform at my highest level in cycling, and 13 years previously doing the same in gymnastics, I have one very clear insight: the mind leads the body.  I know this is pretty common knowledge these days, but as an athlete, I became aware of the conditioned corners of the brain which need just as much training as what the body needs. Despite the hours of hard physical training, it is the mind and our thoughts which allow the end performance.

Furthermore, how could this theory be used to create better outcomes for people wanting to succeed in general life?  I want to study how the conditioning of the brain can be changed in minor ways, to create major performance differences in people who are regularly choosing to under-perform in their day to day decision making.


Throughout my learning at Massey and post study, I will need to understand the written research from others, as well as share my research with others. I have chosen to take Communication in the Sciences so I can confidently share in the sciences. I hope to finish my time of study with a Bachelor of Science, majoring in Psychology, with minors in Physics and Social Policy.