Sunday, 11 December 2016

Christmas feast 2016; servings of organ donation information

Christmas is fast approaching. In NZ we are encouraged to shower ourselves in the spoils which this country allows. Who's house are we celebrating at this year?  Are we going to have seafood and lamb, or ham and turkey? Should we drink wine, beer, spirits or all three? Which flavour chocolate should I choose from Roses chocolate box? Of course, the options in front of us all have their pros and cons and we probably prefer one privilege over another. However, at days end, these yuletide questions are of no consequence, and we can be confident that any choice we make will have a positive outcome. 

This year, in the build-up to Christmas, I have been studying the differing viewpoints in the debate surrounding organ transplantation, in particular, priority allocation for those committed to healthy living.  Not all the choices laid out before us regarding the ultimate gift-of-life will have a positive outcome for those involved and therefore the topic is a highly debated and controversial array of alternatives. It is certainly no box of chocolates.

While studying different literature I soon learned that wringing out the essentials from each piece of literature required critical review. With so many avenues to consider, I decided to chose one article which steers towards ideas repeated in more than a couple of sources. The other article, I decided to pick an article which delved into a new idea for discussion.

My number one article was: Tongs "Community Preferences for the Allocation of Solid Organs for Transplantation". It bore the same fruits as other articles which I found. Like others, it leant towards a variety of predilections from the general public. Any Article bearing a title with the word 'Community' within its heading was bound to look at a broad audience for its conclusion, a conclusion which offered a balanced view of principles involved in allocating donated organs. These principles included efficiency, social, ethical, and medical values.  Above all, I felt the article was written to offer insight into a wide range of public opinion, rather than to persuade. 

My second choice of an article conveyed a unique idea; Persad and others share with us The Lancet journal article 'Principles for allocation of scarce medical interventions'. The authors give accounts of allocation principles which have been used individually, and in different formulas, to create assessment systems for organ and other medical intervention allocation. Instead of simply explaining why the principles are popular within communities, the authors analyse how the use of such principles individually or together as systems can be flawed. The position of the paper is to introduce to the audience a new system which they believe will be fair in successfully allocating scarce medical interventions.

 Both of these articles, full of information, give a clear indication that the subject of organ donor allocation is both complex and the debate is relevant to the community as a whole. With so much information on the subject and so much at stake, it is essential that the discussion continues until there are clear guidelines for allocation of organs with maximum benefits. Thankfully, much information is available for more discussion on the topic. Having access to the internet for research replicates the bounty of the NZ Christmas; the internet serves up a plethora of information, just as Christmas serves up an abundance of gluttony. 

Sources discussed:
- Tong, A., et al. (2010). Community Preferences for the Allocation of Solid Organs for Transplantation: A Systematic Review. Transplantation 89(7): 796-805.

- Persad, G., et al. Principles for allocation of scarce medical interventions. The Lancet 373(9661): 423-431.

8 comments:

  1. Another interesting and well written blog Lease.I particularly enjoyed the introduction which linked your subject matter directly to the topic of your assignment, i.e. food/health. You threaded this theme throughout the blog, and wrapped it up nicely within the last sentence. The subject matter gave me a feel for the complexity of the arguments which you presented with a balanced approach. Looking forward to reading your assignment. Shane

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank You Shane! On re-reading the blog above, I feel that I could have structured it differently to make it easier for the reader. However, I am glad you enjoyed it and that you felt that the theme threaded throughout the blog linked it together! The linking of the theme may have saved it!

      I read Alec's Blog for week 3, and he is very clear with how he structures his writing. Everything sits in order which makes it easy to read. In the future, I will try his method.

      I will send you through my assignment one today so you can read it in readiness for our meeting Saturday. So looking forward to the next assignment and getting to work with my new study friends!
      Lease

      Delete
  2. As we wrote about the same topic, its always nice to admire the research you found. Your writing this week seems more poetic and engaging. I like the way you presented both pieces of research.

    I will check into those resources too, hopefully you found mine useful! there was not a tonne of research out there for our topic. Did you find that it was difficult to get accurate research ?

    I enjoyed your introduction, the time of year is manic and I already feel I have eaten more then I usually do in a week and its not even Christmas yet!

    Thanks Lease !
    Cheers to another week. Look forward to your next blog.

    Lauren

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Lauren. Yes, I did struggle to find relevant information on our particular topic. The "plethora of information found on the internet" that I refer to in my blog was about organ donation in general. However, regardless of the amount of literature on the subject in general, I could not find specific information regarding guidelines for patients to meet waiting list criteria. Since the assignment closure, I have found a couple of great references, but they are more ethical based literature. I think it will be good to share info with each other for assignment two so we can search out this subject. I found the lack of pertinent information a barrier to completing my assignment. However, two minds are greater than one.
      I look forward to working with you.
      Lisa

      Delete
  3. Hi Lease

    I wonder what approach you personally took to the allocation of organs after reading the two different perspectives about the best way to allocate them? I look forward to seeing how you used these sources in your assignment and how this influenced your writing.

    Alec

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Alec.
      Well, funny you should ask that. I personally took the approach that NZ needs some clearer guidelines on who is eligible for an organ, and why. With a shortage of organs, NZ could take it one step further and have a system which gives preference to those who will give an organ the benefit of maximum use. Obviously, the second option, preferencing a recipient, is ethically very hard to back.
      I look forward to reading more on the subject of ethics, as I work through the assignment two with you all.
      Lisa

      Delete
  4. Love the introduction to this blog, I think it was a light way to lead into a more serious discussion. Your so right about the literature, its very time consuming and a little hard at first to actually get those key little pieces you need from it to build your discussion. Sounds like you found some really beneficial pieces of literature to aid you in your assignment one. Also like how you tied your blog all together at the end by re introducing the idea of your intro.
    Jordan

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank You Jordan.
      It is going to be great in assignment two when our group are able to share references with each other and nut out ideas as a team. The discussion around ethics is particuarly hard, and more challenging when a group of people who do not know each other are expected to work on a position as one. It seems, however that our team has gelled pretty well already!
      Thanks for your feedback on my blog Jordan.
      Lease

      Delete