Sunday, 5 February 2017
Surrender the "Me" for the "We".
"Good teams become great ones when the members surrender the 'Me' for the 'We'" (Jackson, 2011).
Engaging and connecting - the team.
What good are the individual attributes, attitudes, and abilities of members of a team, if they are not directed to the common goal? The common goal in this instance was issued by our tutors at Massey University, with a request that we form a team of five members, produce a report, and then present the report as a seminar. We gathered a group of five. Then with an appetite for success, Team Awesomeness (our team's name), engaged and connected using email and a shared Google Docs page. Our Google Docs page, which was aptly named 'Ideas', was soon found to be good for ideas, but not for its team building ability. Email communication was better, as personalities and friendships were more comfortably formed, however, the number of emails being shared made it both complex and confusing to follow conversations. We all agreed that face to face would be ideal. However, with our members located over the length of New Zealand, Skype conference call was the next best thing. Skype conferencing did not allow for face to face communication. Therefore, it lacked the allowance of facial expression, body language, and the compliment of the tone of voice to assist members to learn about one another quickly and comprehend concepts of conversations faster. Still, it was by far our best option for communication, and therefore we decided to meet via Skype conference at least once a week for the duration of the report and the seminar assignments.
Our team solidified a sound relationship quickly, and all the members displayed a 'both feet in' type attitude on the outset. We quickly formulated a plan to write a report to the local Minister of Parliament, with the aim to encourage a change to the current organ donation system in New Zealand.
Hindsight is a beautiful thing.
Without understanding that we were required to adopt only one ethical framework to back our recommendations in the report, we went about discussing various frameworks and decided to cover more than one. Our first three weeks of planning, research, and composition of the report were based on a combination of these frameworks. It wasn't until the last part of writing the report that we understood we were meant to concentrate on a single ethical framework. I felt that it had also taken this long for the team to start to understand each other, and grasp how we needed to work together to create success.
In hindsight, I now see that as a team we were late starters regarding confidently breaking down the task and discussing it thoroughly. As we got to know each other better we began to discuss the task more in depth. In hindsight, I also can see that better leadership could have assisted a faster and more thorough communication method. I was the team leader during the report assignment.
On reflection of my role, I let things cruise along for too long, not implementing a sense of urgency into my team. I should have added a touch of Belbins 'Shaper' and ' The Monitor Evaluator' leadership styles, to work alongside my prominent style of 'Coordinator', as those roles tend to prompt the team to keep to the task and bring more critical thinking to process. My love of people and my love of encouraging the best out of people means that I often lead with Belbin's 'Coordinator' style role. I felt this leadership role would also work well with team members I did not know well.
As I share my passion for creating enthusiasm and ability with a passion creating success in everything I do, I realised that I needed to share being a 'Coordinator' with a role of an 'Implementer', who is someone disciplined and loves doing the job they are asked to do. The Servant role explained in the leadership video shown in week five's lessons on our Massey University Communication in the Sciences Stream Page, also attracted me. The Servant role's concept to neutralise the relationship between leader and follower, and it's bequeathing style, encourages a follower who feels trust and appreciation for their leader. The servant leader creates a heightened confidence from the team, which is accompanied by a motivation to do their best.
One drops away:
As the weeks went on 4 of us realised that Jordan was not as motivated as the rest of the team. Jordan was not supporting the team in a united effort, or even individually getting any work done for her good results. When I look back the passive nature which accompanies both the 'Coordinator' and the 'Servant' roles meant that I was more motivated to work hard for myself and those interested in working well towards the report than I was to ensure the whole team was fully on board. Therefore, I overlooked the fact that Jordan's input was slipping away, and I did nothing to proactively get her involved. I now feel responsible for letting Jordan slip away. The result is that we ended up working mostly with just four members.
Introverts as leaders.
Belbin identified nine roles which he believed were required to make the team into a successful working unit. Belbin gives no mention of introverts or extroverts in his description of the characteristics and performances of team players. However, I recognised a link between Belbin's role definitions and extraverts or introverts. On reading the Oxford Dictionary (2015), extroverts are people who tend to be stimulated by a social and physical climate rather than inner thoughts and reflection. Introverted people are those who's ability and function is accelerated by working and operating alone. As soon as I begun communication with Alec, I recognised traits in him congruent with being an introvert. I gel well with introverts and respect them highly. There is something to be said about a person who has a natural ability to reflect on circumstance rather than speak about it. After all, we were given two ears and just one mouth for a reason.
Interestingly, I had also categorised him into two of Belbin's roles, which I had already identified as roles fit for a more introverted personality. What was more interesting was that although I would rate him highly on an introvert scale, I felt he identified with two of Belbin's leadership style roles; Shaper, and Monitor evaluator. I had always thought that leadership was for extraverts, but Alec's combination of introvert and leadership traits now have me thinking otherwise.
Alec's natural Shaper traits came into play at the end when the report needed finishing and finishing fast. I felt the only thing which he lacked in leadership was the imbalance between focusing on the task at hand and communicating with the team. I must consider, however, that he may have chosen not to communicate with the team because he was not the leader. He did ensure that he communicated with me at all times, and therefore may have decided that it was my job, as team leader to communicate with the team on his behalf. Which in hindsight was a very sensible use of his skill and time I believe.
Lauren and Shane.
Lauren's strong points were her skill set with computer technology. Along with being a 'Specialist' in the Belbin team roles, she accompanied that with a team worker and a completer finisher. This made her a great leader when we were completing the seminar assignment because we needed media leadership, and a detailed approach to the energy of the team started to diminish.
Shane was our rock because he boasted an array of qualities and attributes which aligned with 6 of Belbin's team roles. This meant that when one person in the team was tired or not present, he could lift the team by fitting into that role on the day. He worked extremely hard for the team, reworking his parts of the report when we decided to change the focus of our report to just one ethical framework instead of a combination. Shane remained as secretary throughout both the report and the seminar assignment, as he could always be trusted to be listening to all that was said, and he always showed up to meetings.
The team.
When I consider all nine of Belbin's team roles, our team had them all covered. I was extremely impressed by the work that a small group of strangers could produce. In retrospect, there were issues which could have been fixed quicker with better leadership in the report, and a better understanding of the team members personalities. I look forward to the next time I have to work in a team, now that I have a greater understanding of team roles and leadership styles.
References:
Carnegie, D., (1936) How to win friends and influence people. Simon and Schuster. United States of America.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
This was a fully considered and in-depth blog Lease. You raise an interesting point about introverts and extroverts and linking this in to the Belbin Roles helped to clarify them even further for me. I applaud your honesty regarding your positive and negative comments particularly as this may have been a difficult thing to do. This is also an important leadership skill so good on you for tackling it head on. I really enjoyed working with you in this team and thank you for your support and leadership of our little team. Go well with all your future endeavours. I expect to hear about you doing amazing things throughout New Zealand and the world. Nga mihi nunui ki a koe e Poto.
ReplyDeleteThanks Shane. I really enjoyed this course, even though I found it a huge challenge and felt it was way over my head unless I worked really hard. The concentrated arrangement of work, and the high level of expectation from the tutors made me work even harder and this made me learn more. I felt very fortunate to have such a neat team of people to do the assignments with. I really appreciate all of you, and feel like I have made some new friends. If you ever want to be in touch, I would love to hear from you and hear how your studies are going. You are an inspiration to people everywhere with your caring and positive outlook on life and all others. Thanks again for everything. lease
Delete