But what happens when codes are based on societal beliefs and norms, instead of what is considered moral?
What are the risks that doctors, scientist, the government, or individuals face when challenging the norms of society?
Can we feel confident that our national codes of ethics protect and support all who are at stake?
Do codes of ethics draw lines which divide what is acceptable and unacceptable in a moral world, or do they reflect the criterion of the public at large?
One would hope that the bulk of the population in New Zealand act morally and insist on codes of ethics for our science communities, which reflect morality.
A well-known example of the past, which challenged morality, are the social laws and ethics which existed in the deep south of America in the late 1700's right through till the introduction of the Thirteenth Amendment in 1865. These codes of ethics were probably based on societal norms rather than moral theories. In the mid-1800's there were an estimated four million slaves living in the United States (Bourne, 2008). Laws within those states not only permitted slavery but encouraged its activity, supporting the cotton industry to bring economic advantage to the region.
Even in current times, ethical codes in some areas of the world reflect the cultural beliefs and traditions of the people, rather than what we would consider moral. Look, for example, at the approval of female circumcision in African and Middle Eastern countries, or the strict government laws against abortion in Ireland. Laws in North Carolina, USA made homosexual activity illegal until as late as 2003. What may seem morally wrong to some, are ethically correct to others, and this is directed by social beliefs and norms.
I have used these social examples to highlight how culture hugely affects what we deem ethical. So, how does the outside world view our ethics codes in New Zealand? In science, I believe there is unethical practice in how we prioritise funding for scientific research and development. What is happening in front of us influences how we spend our resources. If the global crisis in health is not affecting us directly, then where in our codes are we ensuring that we THINK globally? The World Health Organisation (2016) explain in their website that there are parts of the world which are lacking resources to combat diseases. These diseases are killing and disabling millions of people every year.
We have to question if our codes of ethics ensure that New Zealand's scientific research adds value to our global population. Our codes of ethics should steer the science community in New Zealand to minimise the inequality which occurs between first world countries (the founders of scientific research), and those regions which have little or no access to scientific resources of their own. Either through lack of funding, lack of education regarding urgent global issues or a lack of morals, New Zealand tends to funnel what is available, towards the benefit of our own society and financial interests.
Whether we are considering the atrocities of Slavery, the procedure of female circumcision, or prioritising beauty over the treatment of life-threatening diseases, codes of ethics do not always ensure morality, but instead reflect the norms of their founding societies. New Zealand has to continue to question and analyse their codes of Ethics to ensure we are not writing guidelines simply for our own comfort.
References:
Bourne, J. (2008, March). Slavery in the United States. EH.Net Encyclopedia. Retrieved from http://eh.net/encyclopedia/slavery-in-the-united-states/
World Health Organisation. (2016). Why are some tropical diseases called neglected? Retrieved from http://www.who.int/features/qa/58/en/
I often wonder Lisa what the future thinkers will think of us (the current mankind) in say 150 to 200 years. I am certain that they will be shaking their heads in disbelief at many of our current practices which are considered (if not argued dubiously) as ethical, and based on so called sound moral reasoning. Unfortunately the western world in my opinion has forsaken ethics for profits. How else could pharmaceuticals have so much influence in our health system yet never be held to account for creating and killing more addicts than all the illicit drug users combined? And who are filling our prisons? Certainly not the corporates who are robbing the nation blind not to mention the rest of the world, while creating third class citizens forced into a life of degradation and crime. You have raised some very interesting points Lisa, particularly on how the ‘culture’ of a people influences the ethics. What about the culture of greed? Certainly that was prevalent in the slave trade as you mentioned but how far have we really come? Is the minimum wage (or New Zealand’s wage scale for that matter) not just a form of modern slavery? A really great blog to get us thinking Lisa.
ReplyDeleteHi Shane, thanks for your comment on my blog.
DeleteYou are right; there are some accepted norms amongst today's culture already which need reconsideration now. Some of those accepted standards may not seem so wrong in the immediate present, but the longer we hesitate to question their morality, the more they will become part of our traditional culture. How they will influence our culture in the future, is more of a concern. I wonder how the atrocities of slavery started. I am sure that most people would have thought it disgusting, but the longer it became accepted by some, the more the idea of slavery blended itself into the minds and cultures of South America. Worse, if the higher class and leaders of America were using slavery for their success, then that behaviour would have looked 'successful.'
I believe that those we consider as role models and leaders in our communities can do most harm or good. When certain ways of living are accepted by those we consider great, the more likely that way of life is accepted as great. I believe that role models and leaders have the same psychological effect that advertising has on people, they arose emotions in their audience which creates a canvas for influence.
You have raised a good point in your comment; when considering some of the controversial moral issues of today, the controversy so often lies in the concern that decisions are hanging on greed, rather from moral standings.
ReplyDeleteHi Lease,
I really appreciate you bringing up the disparities in research funding distribution. The more my peers and I progress in the scientific world, the more we are becoming aware that the people who have the money really do control the research. It’s a problem aggravated by the media as well; we saw this during the Ebola outbreak. Western media largely ignored it until it posed a risk to their demographic, and after that there was a lot of misinformed hysteria. That was a really good and well written blog post.
Thanks,
Alec